1985 22-12 Tell City Mater DeiYear Score Champion Runner-up
1986 14-12 Tell City Mater Dei
1987 34-6 Mater Dei South Spencer
1988 20-0 South Spencer Mater Dei
1989 21-17 Mater Dei South Spencer
1990 27-13 Mater Dei Heritage Hills
1991 28-7 Tell City South Spencer
1992 8-0 Tell City Providence
1993 32-0 Mater Dei Linton
1994 34-6 Mater Dei North Posey
1995 38-28 North Posey Southridge
1996 35-0 North Posey Southridge
1997 34-6 Mater Dei South Spencer
1998 40-20 Mater Dei North Posey
1999 42-21 Mater Dei Southridge
2000 40-6 Mater Dei Tell City
2001 45-22 Mater Dei Southridge
2002 19-9 Southridge South Spencer
2003 38-13 South Spencer North Posey
2004 55-34 Southridge North Posey
2005 28-7 North Posey South Spencer
2006 52-20 Southridge North Posey
2007 14-13(OT)Southridge Mater Dei
2008 42-28 Southridge North Posey
2009 28-7 Mater Dei North Posey
2010 28-21 Mater Dei Southridge
2011 39-21 Mater Dei Southridge
2012 42-0 Mater Dei South Spencer
2013 21-19 Southridge Mater Dei
2014 28-9 Mater Dei North Posey
2015 49-7 Mater Dei North Posey
2016 56-20 Mater Dei South Spencer
2017 38-31(OT)Southridge Mater Dei
2018 35-25 Southridge Mater Dei
2019 35-6 Mater Dei North Knox
2020 37-20 Mater Dei Linton
2021 42-13 Mater Dei North Posey
2022 35-0 Mater Dei North Posey
2023 35-14 North Posey Paoli
Note: Sectional 32 was renumbered as sectional 40 with the addition of the 6th class.