Heritage Hills High School officially opened January 1973, midway through the 1972–1973 school year. During the fall of 1972, students still attended Dale High School and Chrisney High School, but football was played under the Heritage Hills name, with home games at Dale. Because the campuses remained separate until January, both schools selected Homecoming Queens.
1947 • 1952
None
1964 — Donnie Kirkland, AAA Cardinals organization
1964 — Eric Ayer, Ole Miss
N/A — Jim Haaf, Oakland City College
N/A — Edmond Cissna, Indiana State
N/A — Clyde Parker, Kentucky & Louisville click here
1943 — Glen Parker, Kentucky & Louisville click here
1967 — Bruce Cissna, Indiana Rivers college in Florida two years and Ball State 1 year
1971 — Gary Trafton, University of Evansville
N/A — Edmond Cissna, Indiana State
1951 — Billy Livengood, Wake Forest
1957 — Roger Kaiser, Georgia Tech
1957 — Bob Reinhart, Indiana University
1957 — Roger Kaiser, Georgia Tech; ABA Washington & Philadelphia
1957 — Bob Reinhart, Kentucky Wesleyan & Indiana University
1958 — John Clark, Indiana State
1965 — Stan Guth, Georgia Tech
1966 — Roger Guth, Evansville
1948 — James Paul Roos, Evansville College
1971 — Stan Jochim, Hanover College
Dale (11): 1934, 1937, 1938, 1939, 1940, 1944, 1949, 1956, 1957, 1958, 1968
Chrisney (2): 1965, 1969
1938 — 3-2
1939 — 7-1
1940 — 2-6
1941 — 3-5
1946 — 6-1
1947 — 8-0
1948 — 6-2-1
1949 — 2-7
1950 — 3-7
1951 — 3-5-1
1952 — 7-1-1
1953 — 2-6
1954 — 0-8
1955 — 3-5
1956 — 3-4-1
1957 — 2-6
1958 — 1-7
1959 — 3-5
1960 — 2-6
1961 — 4-4
1962 — 3-4-1
1963 — 5-3
1964 — 3-4-1
1965 — 4-3-1
1966 — 2-6
1967 — 4-4
1968 — 1-8
1969 — 4-6
1970 — 5-5
1971 — 8-2
