* denotes school record (boys or girls)
Only have school records for categories where data exists for both boys and girls.
Rebekah Gordon and Darren Burnett are tied for the school record for points in a game.
Points, Rebounds, 3‑Point Field Goals, Free Throw %, and Assists are the five categories with school records listed.
| Points | ||||
| Game | Darren Burnett | 41 | 02/12/83 | * |
| Season | Trent Sisley | 657 | 2022–23 | * |
| Career | Trent Sisley | 1715 | 2022–2024 | * |
| Field Goals | ||||
| Game | Darren Burnett | 16 | 02/12/83 | |
| Game | Jay Cutler | 16 | 12/10/99 | |
| Season | Trent Sisley | 252 | 2022–23 | |
| Career | Trent Sisley | 665 | 2022–2024 | |
| Rebounds | ||||
| Game | Darrell Green | 29 | 1973 | * |
| Season | Trent Sisley | 274 | 2023–24 | * |
| Career | Trent Sisley | 751 | 2022–2024 | * |
| Field Goal % | ||||
| Season | Klint Arnold | 66.1% | 1987–88 | |
| Career | Trent Sisley | 61.0% | 2022–24 | |
| Free Throws | ||||
| Game | Mike Troth | 16 | 12/5/89 | |
| Season | Phil Wahl | 131 | 1984–85 | |
| Career | Trent Sisley | 305 | 2022–2024 | |
| Free Throw % | ||||
| Season | Devon Merder | 89.9% | 2013–2014 | * |
| Career | Devon Merder | 83.7% | 2011–2014 | * |
| 3‑Point Field Goals | ||||
| Game | Nathan Schorr | 7 | 1/13/95 & 1/8/94 | * |
| Game | Ben Lambeck | 7 | 2/22/91 | * |
| Game | Gavin Schaefer | 7 | 1/05/13 | * |
| Game | Alec Meunier | 7 | 12/12/15 | * |
| Game | JT Smallwood | 7 | 12/18/20 & 1/15/22 | * |
| Season | Jeff Hein | 67 | 1987–88 | * |
| Career | Simon Scherry | 158 | 2017–2020 | |
| 3‑Point % | ||||
| Season | Simon Scherry | 52.5% | 2018–19 | |
| Career | Tim Denning | 45.7% | 1994–1998 | |
| Assists | ||||
| Game | Simon Scherry | 16 | 2/14/2020 | * |
| Season | Simon Scherry | 195 | 2019–2020 | * |
| Career | Simon Scherry | 415 | 2017–2020 | * |