1989
Kim Brown
Anderson University
1990
Pam Mulzer
Depauw University
1995
Sara Steckler
Marian College
1996
Vicki Painter
Earlham College
1997
Theresa Smith
Hanover University
1999
Tonya Schum
Olney Central College
2010
Lyndsi Woolems
Luther College
2013
Kaebra LaGrange
Oakland City University
2018
Abby Wahl
Eastern Illinois University & Utah State University
2021
Rebekah Gordon
Central Michigan University & USC Upstate
2022
Hadley Lytton
Kentucky Wesleyan College