2000 - Brian Michel - Hanover College - Men's Soccer
2001 - Jody Morrison - Oakland City University - Men's Soccer
2001 - Dan Waninger - Manchester College - Men's Soccer
2004 - Jay Whitney - University of Southern Indiana - Men's Soccer
2006 - Brandon Gengelbach - Oakland City University - Men's Soccer
2007 - Cody Schaefer - IUPUI - Men's Soccer
2008 - Sam Waninger - Kentucky Wesleyan - Men's Soccer
2008 - Alex Utter - Indiana Tech - Men's Soccer
2008 - James White - Indiana Tech - Men's Soccer
2009 - Kyle Etienne - University of Southern Indiana - Men's Soccer
2010 - Jesse Waninger - University of Indianapolis - Men's Soccer
2011 - Nick Snyder - Kentucky Wesleyan - Men's Soccer
2011 - Andrew Broshears - Kentucky Wesleyan - Men's Soccer
2012 - Cody Leffert - Kentucky Wesleyan - Men's Soccer
2012 - Sophie Etienne - University of Evansville - Women's Soccer
2012 - Missy Brown - Oakland City University - Women's Soccer
2015 - Breigh Haase - Kentucky Wesleyan College - Women's Soccer
2015 - Karoline Staggs - Kaskaskia College (IL) - Women's Soccer
2016 - Seth Bolin - Kentucky Christian University - Men's Soccer
2016 - Dria Oxley - Kaskaskia College - Women's Soccer
2018 - Kerrigan Mulzer - Western Kentucky - Women's Soccer
2020 - Kiersten Schuler - Kentucky Wesleyan College - Women's Soccer
2021 - Haley Osborne - Indiana University & Kentucky Wesleyan - Women's Soccer
2023 - Chelsey Tempel - Earlham College - Women's Soccer
2023 - Kylie Duncan - Blackburn College - Women's Soccer
2025 - Anna Klueh - Kentucky Wesleyan College - Women's Soccer