2003
Kristy Groves
Norfolk State & University of Southern Indiana
2006
Sarah Funston
Morehead State
2006
Claire Collins
John A. Logan College
2006
Kiyla Spurlock
Rend Lake College
2008
Kelly Bettag
Iowa Wesleyan
2008
Erica McBride
Missouri Valley & Kentucky Wesleyan
2009
Hanna Bettag
Indiana University–Southeast
2010
Kyla Gogel
Indiana University–Southeast
2010
Jade Detzer
Indiana University–Southeast
2011
Danielle Hoppenjans
Brescia University
2014
Kayala Hoppenjans
Olney Central College
2014
Kaitlin Krlj
Wabash Valley College
2016
Jamie Tempel
Kentucky Wesleyan College
2018
Meagan Kralj
Rend Lake
2018
Maddie Fuller
Olney Central College
2019
Lauren Caswell
Southeastern Illinois
2020
Emma Eubank
Ball State University
2020
Miranda Keller
Grace College (Winona Lake, IN)
2024
Rylie Schipp
Eastern Illinois University
2024
Grace Keller
Indiana Tech University
2025
Amelia Kiegel
University of Southern Indiana
2025
Miriam Gordon
Tennessee State University
2026
Nevaeh Hayden
Saint Mary of the Woods College
2026
Haley Fisher
Olney Central College