2002
Tom Aigner
Rose‑Hulman
Men's Wrestling
2002
Zach Goldsberry
University of Indianapolis
Men's Wrestling
2005
Phillip Knepper
Cumberland College
Men's Wrestling
2006
Cody Weiss
Rend Lake College
Men's Wrestling
2007
Cole Konerding
University of Southern Indiana
Men's Wrestling
2010
Jeff Weiss
University of Indianapolis
Men's Wrestling
2013
Jared Boehm
University of Indianapolis
Men's Wrestling
2014
Jake Rickenbaugh
University of Indianapolis
Men's Wrestling
2018
Josh Bell
Simpson College
Men's Wrestling
2020
Phoenix Rodgers
University of Indianapolis
Men's Wrestling
2020
Sam Scott
University of Mount Olive
Men's Wrestling
2023
Brenden Chew
Kentucky Wesleyan College
Men's Wrestling
2024
MaKenzie Smith
Indiana Tech University
Women's Wrestling
2026
Hayden Smith
Grand Valley State University
Men's Wrestling
2026
Dalton Pledger
Marian University Indianapolis
Men's Wrestling