(Minimum 1,400 points and up)
| Year | Name | Points | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Alaysha Brandenberger | 1848 | Boonville |
| 2026 | Emily Parker | 1843 | Boonville |
| 2024 | Chloey Graham | 1740 | Gibson Southern |
| 1991 | Tricia Deffendoll | 1621 | Pike Central |
| 2004 | Leslie Ricker | 1582 | North Posey |
| 1995 | Haley Harris | 1573 | Wood Memorial |
| 2004 | Laura McClintic | 1558 | Tell City |
| 1984 | Marilyn Reckelhoff | 1494 | Southridge |
| 2016 | Maddie Raley | 1490 | Gibson Southern |
| 1995 | Adrienne Seitz | 1480 | Pike Central |
| 2018 | Abby Wahl | 1450 | Heritage Hills |
| 2026 | Allie Taylor | 1412 | Princeton |
Note: The 3-point shot was added in 1987.
Note: These are players whose schools were members of the PAC when they played.
Additional note: Alaysha Brandenberger’s team joined the PAC her junior season. Laura McClintic played two years at Cannelton.
Additions or corrections: email mosbeyd@yahoo.com